631.553.8824                        TheBaker@ACakeInTime.com                         631.553.8824            

Raving Fans...

What our happy customers are saying....

"Hey Sherry! Everyone loved the cake!  At the end of the night I didn't have any cards left!  You might be getting an inquiry for a Madagascar cake! :)   I am glad I was able to take a lot of pictures of the cake before everyone came because the guests were surrounding it all night!  I'm not sure who got more attention - your cake or mom to be!"
 
T.T., NYC
 
"Thanks again for the adorable cupcakes! The kids faces were priceless when they peeked in the box to see them. I wasn't there when they ate them but my Logan said everybody loved them and ate them all up!!! I got an email from the class mom saying the cupcakes I brought in were awesome!!! Looking forward to the cookies." 
Thanks, Lisa C 

 IT WAS AWESOME!!!!
NOT A PIECE LEFT. PEOPLE ATE MORE THAN 1 SLICE......BRAVO!!!

 

B.C., NYC
 

"Everything went wrong at my daughters party (the pizza was late, the music didn’t work, bowling lanes weren’t working well). All I can say is thank goodness for this cake! This cake literally SAVED my party! Fortunately, my guests could not stop looking and talking about this cake. It was a fabulous distraction from all the mishaps. And then when the guests ate the cake they couldn’t get over its unbelievable flavor. I would never have another party without having “A Cake in Time” cake!!!!" 

J.M., Oceanside, NY (Bowling Cake)

"I just wanted to send you a quick note to thank you for the beautiful cake you made for my husband's 40th birthday. It was absolutely perfect. It was classy, but happy and very yummy. Everybody loved it! Thanks again!"

M.B., Manhattan, NY

"I have to tell you, it was amazing looking and delicious. Everyone was raving, I mean really raving about it. Ethan ripped off one of the cookie buildings as soon as the cake was put down in front of him and he loved it. I have to say that the baby-to-be and I loved the cookies and the cake. I have a rice krispy car for tomorrow along with lots of leftovers. I can't thank you enough. In fact I had friends still talking about it tonight. Now, I have to give your name and number to everyone. I have no doubt your business is going to be a huge success!"

K.S., Manhattan, NY

"The cake looked and tasted AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! you did such an awesome job. Nobody believed us that it was a real cake at first. They all thought Elmo was a big cake topper. Thank you so very much for the wonderful job. You are an amazing cake artist and baker and I can't thank you enough for making his cake so super special. I had 4 guests ask for a business card and our clown asked too!! We will DEFINITELY be calling you on our next birthday."
 
Thank you! R.P., G.P. and R.P. (Furry Red Creature Cake)

"WOW WOW WOW, Thank you sooo much!

 Is all I can say! The cake looked and tasted unbelievable. You really outdid yourself. I cant stop raving about this cake. My mother was sooo surprised, she even tried to pick it up at first. Every guest at the party was in awe of the cake, and everyone was able to take a piece home. I distributed all of your cards and even still telling people about you by mouth and showing your website. You will definitely be hearing from me again in the near future for another cake. If your carrot cake was this delicious, can't wait to try your Red Velvet cake (thats my favorite). I already told my boyfriend that I want one of your cakes for my b.day!

 Another compliment came from the restaurant owner/chef (Luigi) himself. "He stated that he makes carrot cake at the restaurant and he can never get it as moist as you did! She really did a great job, not only on the outside but inside as well."

 Let me know how to leave a review on your website, so that I can rave some more!!!

 Again, thank you thank you thank you."

 

S.M., Long Island, NY (Coach Bag)

 

The cake was the biggest hit - Eriks friends were taking pictures to show their parents and friends. They all went crazy when the people brought the cake out I wish I had taken a video so you could see the reaction your cake got. The restaurant people loved it and everyone was so afraid to cut it. it was so good! Loved the marble and vanilla together - fantastic! Thank you so much for all of the hard work you put into the Nike cake - it was just what we wanted.

 

Michelle (Nike Sneaker Cake)
 

"The cake was great. It really looked good.  The cake tasted like a devil dog.  Everyone loved it.  TY for  making his birthday special.
 

J.T., Bellmore, NY

 

"Sherry - he loved it and we all loved it! Thanks so much!"  

KL, ELmont, NY


"Sherry, on behalf of myself, Emily and all her friends, THANK YOU SO MUCH for the beautiful and delicious and fabulous cake for Emily's Sweet 16!  It could not have been more perfect in every way!  Thank you soo soo much!!"

LM, Greenlawn, NY (Candy Covered Tier Cake)

"You couldn't have made my day any more special - This cake topped it all!!! It was gorgeous and tasted as great as it looked. The BEAUTIFUL details were to perfection as I'm sure my baby granddaughter will be!! I thank you, my daughter thanks you, and I'm sure when the storks brings our baby girl, she'd thank you too!"

 THANKS FROM ALL OF US - PS, CS and AS, BROOKLYN, NY (Stork and Baby Carriage Cake)

Everyone loved the cake!!! I couldn't resist a piece (don’t usually eat cake) and I had a second slice!!! It was sooooooooooo delicious. I saw a few of the girls go back for more. I copied your card you gave me and gave it to a couple of the ladies. Hope you get a call from it. One girl mentioned she needs a groom’s cake. Thank you so much. I will definitely be calling on you again, and again....  (it was delicious this morning too!  Ask my husband and my 4yr old...)

L.C., St. James, NY

"...I was just raving about the guitar cake the other day. Dave's sister was down here from Mammoth Lakes (a ski resort in the Sierras) where she owns a breakfast restaurant. She also does baked goods (cheesecakes, etc) for many of the restaurants in that town as well as doing many wedding cakes. My rave was that not only was it amazing to look at, but it really was probably close to the most amazing tasting cake I've ever had! The conversation went such that we all agreed that usually if it looks spectacular (like those cake shows on the food network), they usually don't taste that great...but you got an A+ from me on both!!!"

L.E., LA, California

"Hey Sherry -  I just wanted to thank you for the Fantastic Cake, it not only looked great but tasted great as well. I woke up the next morning to find the guy face down on a paper plate on my kitchen counter, (Nancie saved him,) it was kinda how I felt." Thanks again!"

K.T., Rnokonkoma, NY

 

 

Visit Us On Facebook!
Facebook